Sunday Morning Reads
I’m still trying to figure why NYC overwhelmed me last week. I’ve been there before but this time I couldn’t find the energy for it. I didn’t plan any shows, or touristy stuff (I still need to see –yes, simply see—the Statue of Liberty). I didn’t even try to get tickets to see the Knicks! Even without all of that, this was a once in a lifetime visit, and it lived up to the hype. I was there as a judge on the National Book Award for Young People’s Literature Committee to attend the annual ceremony.

I’ve served on a few other award committee. I think this was the smallest I’ve been on, and I’m sure the only with professional writers. Like other organizations, the National Book Foundation provides enough general parameters to allow judges to complete their work in ways that they find meaningful. For me, this always evolves into an opportunity to learn more about books and to develop a greater appreciation for literature. Imagine being in a book club with four of your favorite writers, each from a different genre. You quickly learn to trust their expertise and from that you lean in, trusting the work ahead.
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
I value this process and the ways those who create, publish, read, and award youth literature have become more inclusive. It’s still not perfect. I still see books that, regardless of intention, will transmit stereotypes rather than the real lived experiences of marginalized people. Stories that work to be inclusive are still too often left inaccessible to readers because they’re not published, not marketed, not submitted for awards, not acquired by libraries or bookstores, or not sent to conferences.
And then, they’re censored.
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
I bring this lens to books. Then I read David Levithan, Elana K. Arnold, Julian Randall, Tae Keller, and Keala Kendall and I’m immersed in the finest subtext, character development, relatability, plot structure, point of view, thematic development and such and, from there, I have to help pick one best book.
I’ve long been someone who has believed in lists over winners. Capitalism has us focusing on winners, on competing one creative voice against another when what we’re really trying to do is recognize some of the best. Read David Levithan and Gabriel Duckels’ The Fight of Our Lives: AIDS in America (Knopf) because it is just that good, but also read the other nine books on our longlist because they too, are just that good. I believe the beauty of the work that Brandi Colbert, Anne Ursa, Tricia Ebervia, Jerrett Krosoczka and I did this year is in the community of our longlist.

The highlight of all of this is the Annual Ceremony and Benefit Dinner. It was learning that I cannot trust that I remembered to silence my phone. Being awed at meeting Eve Ewing and Edwidge Dandicat and conversing with them like we are old friends rather than fan girling them. There was that reminder to always be prepared for someone to ask what was your favorite book. It was being asked my thoughts about AI and literature and two days later forming my response that the only thing that makes each of us unique is our story and it’s sharing those stories that connects us. AI can’t do that. It was an evening with dear friends I rarely see any more and meeting with my committee friends for the first time in real life. It was an evening where this introvert didn’t feel my energy being drained by all the people around me, i think because we were all there to celebrate books. It was having Kyle MacLachlan read from his favorite childhood story throughout the ceremony, reminding everyone of the importance of children’s literature in our lives. David and Gabriel’s commentaries made it clear that literature for young people belonged there in that mix, we belong with the grown-ups because we are where it begins.
This was the year that the committee should have dined at the same table at the celebration and our authors should have been with us. If you get a chance to check any one of the creators of the longlisted books online, you’ll see what a community they’ve formed with each other. They make me so proud to be in the kidlit community.
Why do awards honor such different books? Because the committees are different, the criteria is different and the committees don’t all read the same books. The Booker Prize is on my radar because I’m excited about the way they’re bringing young people into their new award for children’s literature. I think this is a brilliant way to uplift and market children’s books while embracing children’s opinions.

I feel like I just finished one of the best literary analysis workshops in the country at the same time I’m trying to flex that muscle myself so, I really drank it all in. Trying! I know I’ve made four lifelong friends who I will always trust, admire, and support. Back when I began blogging twenty years ago, I did it to promote young people’s literacy. To me, that meant supporting authors and illustrators who were creating books for them. I think this work has definitely been an extension of that, even it I had to pick just one. Maybe because I could.
Preparing for this was A LOT. There was taking time to bind books to gift to my committee, stressing over finding a dress that would look halfway decent, remembering how to apply makeup, finding time to read Déy, Let the Poets Govern and Mother Tongue, and hoping flights would be in the air when I needed to leave and maybe that’s why I felt overwhelmed when I landed in NYC.
Filed under: Awards
About Edith Campbell
Edith Campbell is Librarian in the Cunningham Memorial Library at Indiana State University. She is a member of WeAreKidlit Collective, and Black Cotton Reviewers. Edith has served on selection committees for the YALSA Printz Award, ALSC Sibert Informational Text Award, ALAN Walden Book Award, the Walter Award, ALSC Legacy Award, and ALAN Nielsen Donelson Award. She is currently a member of ALA, BCALA, NCTE NCTE/ALAN, REFORMA, YALSA and ALSC. Edith has blogged to promote literacy and social justice in young adult literature at Cotton Quilt Edi since 2006. She is a mother, grandmother, gardener and quilter.
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
SLJ Blog Network
Think Succession… for Kids. It’s a Gordon Korman Cover Reveal and Q&A for The Favorite!
I Witnessed: The Great Train Robbery of 1963 | Review
Friday Exercise: Delineation of Setting
From Policy Ask to Public Voice: Five Layers of Writing to Advance School Library Policy
Sunrise on the Reaping Movie Review
ADVERTISEMENT

