review: Will They, Won’t They

title: Will They, Won’t They
author: Maulik Pancholy
Title: Will They, Won’t They
Date: Kokilia, January 2027
Will They, Won’t They gets its name from the title of the movie embedded inside the book’s story, hinting at the layers of subtext that are ahead. This contemporary gay romance honors Bollywood while using its sense of romance to flavor the book.
Main characters Ajit Jain and Zain Mansoor have one of the most cumbersome meet cutes ever on a yacht while attending a gay wedding in India. Ajit’s nascent talent as a documentary film maker provides him with continuing access to the making of Zain’s first Bollywood film, “Will They Won’t They”. The title teases audiences in the story about the characters in the movie, will they are won’t they fall in love. The marketing campaign for the film has fans across India wondering if Zain and his co-star, Sachi Kapadia, will become a couple in real life. However, readers of the book wonder if Ajit and Zain will, or not. The young men are questioning facets of their identities as well a possible romance. Will they succeed?
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
In making his documentary, Ajit wants to tell the truth about what he sees, but what does that even mean? What is the story he’s trying to tell in his movies? He interviews the tailor who hand stitches mirrors into saris, the henna artist, and a little girl offering ice cream to a beggar because he can’t avoid the contributions of everyone who’s making the movie, regardless how some may regard their status. In a rare moment, Pancholy catches Ajit describing quiet things like darker skin tones that develop from years of toiling in the sun and result in class differentiation. He finds larger issues like the generations of farmers leaving India for opportunities elsewhere. Ajit, who is openly gay, also seems to have quite a chemistry for Zain.
Like Ajit, Zain Mansoor is also trying to find his voice, trying to understand his potential career. For him, it includes establishing himself as an actor, not a nepo baby. His father, one of the most successful Bollywood actors, has taught him that movie stars are owned by the world. How can Zain ever live his own truth?
I particularly appreciated how the narrative questions access and privilege. It’s easy to assume this will be another Indian American romance about the rich and famous, but it’s not. The young men both question their access to resources and develop appreciation for what they’ve been giving. Zain’s awareness peels away slower than Ajit. The most telling scene for him is late in the story. (Locations 2057 of 2544.)
I head into our foyer, past the Bharti Kher statue on this concrete perch, and into the kitchen. Bhanuji is making masala chai over the gas stove.
“Morning Bhanuji.”
“Zain sahib.”
“Please don’t call me that. You’re my elder.”
“How should I address you, then?”
We’ve been over this countless times.
“ ‘Beta,’ “ I say. “It describes our relationship better.” He brings two teacups to the table—one for him, one for me.
Don’t call me sir, he says to this elderly man who has tended to him for years. Zain and Ajit are a new generation, seeing things in new ways without losing regard for their past. Will they or won’t they make a difference?
The main characters are complex and well developed, as are supporting characters. We see them all finding their truths and opening doors for others along the way.
Filed under: Reviews
About Edith Campbell
Edith Campbell is Librarian in the Cunningham Memorial Library at Indiana State University. She is a member of WeAreKidlit Collective, and Black Cotton Reviewers. Edith has served on selection committees for the YALSA Printz Award, ALSC Sibert Informational Text Award, ALAN Walden Book Award, the Walter Award, ALSC Legacy Award, and ALAN Nielsen Donelson Award. She is currently a member of ALA, BCALA, NCTE NCTE/ALAN, REFORMA, YALSA and ALSC. Edith has blogged to promote literacy and social justice in young adult literature at Cotton Quilt Edi since 2006. She is a mother, grandmother, gardener and quilter.
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
SLJ Blog Network
Think Succession… for Kids. It’s a Gordon Korman Cover Reveal and Q&A for The Favorite!
I Witnessed: The Great Train Robbery of 1963 | Review
Friday Exercise: Delineation of Setting
From Policy Ask to Public Voice: Five Layers of Writing to Advance School Library Policy
Sunrise on the Reaping Movie Review
Luke Pearson Made a Picture Book!
ADVERTISEMENT

